Blog
Off-The-Shelf Flight Software: Pros and Cons

Flight software is an essential component of a functioning satellite. It’s what enables the satellite to perform its tasks and carry out its mission, which means finding the right software solution for your satellite is vital.
Those with the right wherewithal in the form of people, finances, and time could develop and employ their own, but for many this isn’t possible. This is where off-the-shelf software becomes an attractive prospect, but what are the advantages and the drawbacks of taking this route?
What is off-the-shelf software?
“Off-the-shelf” refers to software that is readily available to a wider market and is made to meet a commercial need. It can be thought of like any product you might pick up ‘off the shelf’ in a physical shop – anybody can do so without special prerequisite.
Commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) products may not be as specialised to the individual user as a bespoke solution, but that doesn’t mean they can’t be fine-tuned as necessary. Indeed, as they need to serve the market on a wider scale, COTS solutions must be customisable for as many customers as possible.
COTS solutions often provide excellent entry points for those who want to join a sector that has become more accessible thanks to reduced barriers, such as is the case with satellite development.
Off-the-shelf software advantages
Cost
One of the biggest and perhaps most persuasive advantages to off-the-shelf software is that it’s cheaper than a bespoke alternative.
For many in satellite development, particularly those working with SmallSats, this is more than just a nice money-saving option. Being more accessible by nature, CubeSat missions are typically built using readily-available hardware components, and so it makes a lot of sense to bring the off-the-shelf aspect into the software realm as well..
Time
COTS software solutions reduce time to market precisely because they’re ready to be bought and integrated. Even if you factor in the tweaks and optimisation that could be required on the user’s end, off-the-shelf software is far quicker to pick up and integrate than a custom option.
For example, our own Flight Software Development Kit is ready to cover the basic functionalities of a satellite, freeing up important time for the unique and more demanding aspects of development.
Reducing time to market is not simply a bonus, in many cases clawing back precious time can be critical for mission success in the crowded space sector.
Pre-validated and flight-proven software components also mean that there won’t be any nasty surprises later in development or after the satellite is placed in orbit.
Scalable
Quite often, the flexibility of off-the-shelf software is achieved through modular architecture. This allows COST solutions to remain adaptable when the scale of a system grows. In practical terms, this means that the software doesn’t need to be fundamentally redesigned from the ground up to answer a different set of demands to the beginning of a project.
Additionally, this allows in-house tracking of how your software package has changed and grown, facilitating training and traceability that gives you a full history of where your software started, what it’s needed to adapt to, and where it might need to adjust next.
Simplicity
In order to make themselves as widely accessible as possible, COTS solutions are built to be simple and easy to use. This further reduces the time needed to understand and integrate them, as well as making them more supportable from a first-party perspective.
Many vendors, similar to us, offer training and support from the outset, allowing your team’s specialist (or team of specialists) to pick up the software quickly and build a knowledge base for future training and specialisation.
Off-the-shelf solutions can commonly be tried before committing to purchase; so if you’re not sure yet, you can usually book a free demo and try before you buy.
What are the drawbacks to off-the-shelf software?
Off-the-shelf software architecture can be useful for many, but it could equally be constraining for some. Not everybody will get what they need from COTS solutions.
Less control
Since the product itself is controlled by the vendor, who will be updating and changing it as necessary, you may find over time that it no longer resembles what you need or prefer.
If you’re using bespoke software for your satellite mission, this is not a problem, and you can specifically request the changes you need from your own vendor (or your engineers if it’s all been developed in-house).
This is when it becomes really important to ensure your solution – whether in-house or off-the-shelf – remains open and flexible to future change. Modular approach of many COST solutions can often successfully address this issue by allowing user to simply swap the affected components in and out if and when required.
Imperfect fits
Being designed to have wide appeal and useability can mean that off-the-shelf software solutions may be too broadly focused for some. There’s no guarantee that every business will want to take their COTS solution into long-term use, as it may prove to be not exactly what they need as situations or attitudes change.
This can be offset by a lot of vendors allowing free interactive demos of the software before purchases, but you should to be prepared that you might find off-the-shelf solutions not as ideal as you expected.
Long-term cost
Off-the-shelf software starts out as a cheaper option compared to bespoke software, but the structure of licensing costs can become more expensive over the long-term.
As such, the upfront cost of custom software development should be weighed against licensing for the use of a COTS solution for long-term use, as the cumulative cost of the latter could end up being higher.
However, this is so much of a issue in the new space sector, as the lifespan of a satellite tends be limited and it is less likely that your longer-term licensing costs will end up costing you more than in-house development.
Which is best for me?
The best solution for your satellite mission will depend on your time availability, financial budget, and accessible resources in terms of people power. Those who can afford specialised custom software may want to consider the greater control and specificity of that option, but for many, a flexible development kit is the best option for affordability and time.
Bright Ascension’s off-the-shelf flight software
Our Flight Development Software Kit is a pre-validated, configurable route for your satellite mission that cuts costs, saves time, and gives you a wealth of software components at your fingertips. Free up time and simplify your development for a faster time to market.
To learn more about our products or book a free demo, contact us today.